ChinaTalk

Share this post

Just How Bad is Unemployment in China?

www.chinatalk.media

Just How Bad is Unemployment in China?

Jordan Schneider
May 15, 2020
2
Share this post

Just How Bad is Unemployment in China?

www.chinatalk.media

The lockdown measures adopted to curb the spread of the novel coronavirus in Europe and the United States have hit economies hard, leading to soaring unemployment rates. Yet in China, where most indicators have reflected a steep economic downturn, the unemployment rate mysteriously showed nearly no increase over the first quarter of 2020.

In the following article, Li Xunlei, Deputy Chairman of the China Chief Economist Forum and Chief Economist at Zhongtai Securities Research Institute, explains why the official unemployment rate has barely budged in the face of broader economic problems. He does his own calculations to estimate a real unemployment rate around twenty percent, and adds some conjectures as to how these much higher unemployment figures will affect the broader economy.

Below we’re also featuring our first contest winner with a satirical take on a recent off-the-cuff Xi speech. And as always, stick around till the bottom for ‘China Twitter Tweets of The Week.’

How High Is China’s Unemployment Rate?

April 26. Li Xunlei.

Summary

  • The official unemployment rate clearly does not reflect the economic situation in China. Unlike in the United States and Europe, neither official measure of unemployment in China correlates with the business cycle. While most economic indicators indicated a sharp decline in economic activity, the urban surveyed unemployment rate in China increased by 0.7% in the first quarter of 2020.

  • China has two methods, each flawed in their own way, of measuring unemployment. The urban registered unemployment rate only counts those who register as unemployed with the government and does not account for migrant workers at all. In the first quarter of 2020, the number of migrant workers fell by more than fifty million, a group that goes unaccounted for under these unemployment measures. The urban surveyed unemployment rate also undercounts the number of unemployed migrant workers.

  • How high is the unemployment rate? Taking into account sluggish consumer demand and the lagging services industry, the number of newly unemployed people in China may exceed seventy million, corresponding to a 20.5% unemployment rate.

  • Knock on effects: there is no inevitable, V-shaped recovery once the lockdown ends. Shutting down the economy is easier than re-opening it, and problems like reduced income, bankruptcy, and upticks in unemployment will have magnifying effects. That is not to mention the fact that we have yet to cure the coronavirus.

The official unemployment rate is deviating from other economic indicators

In theory, the unemployment rate and the business cycle should be closely, and negatively, correlated. When business is booming, production expands and unemployment decreases. When the business cycle swings downward, production slows and the unemployment rate rises. Because of the relative inelasticity of the labor market, decreases in the unemployment rate often lag behind upswings in the business cycle, meaning that broader economic recovery might not bring immediate job market gains.

[This figure shows the close correlation between GDP growth and unemployment in the United States. The red line indicates unemployment rate, measured on the left y-axis. The gray line indicates GDP growth, measured on the right y-axis in inverse order with negative growth highest on the axis.]

There are two methods used for calculating unemployment in China. The urban registered unemployment rate relies on employees at non-private and private enterprises, as well as self-employed people, to report unemployment to the government. The urban surveyed unemployment rate is calculated using the results of sample surveys in urban areas, and was designed in part to account for migrant workers in cities.

Neither measure of unemployment is highly correlated with the business cycle. For the past twenty years, China’s urban registered unemployment rate has modulated without correlation with broader economic conditions. The urban surveyed unemployment rate, since it began being measured in 2018, has generally had limited volatility, staying persistently around five percent.

[These two figures show the lack of correlation between the unemployment rate and economic activity in China. In the graph on the left, the red line indicates the urban registered unemployment rate, measured on the left y-axis. The gray line indicates the year-on-year change in electricity generation, measured on the right y-axis in inverse order with negative change highest on the axis. In the graph on the right, the red line indicates the urban surveyed unemployed rate, measured on the left y-axis. The gray line indicates year-on-year change in electricity generation, measured on the right y-axis in inverse order with negative change highest on the axis. This graph begins in January 2018, when the Chinese government introduced the urban surveyed unemployed rate.]

The same held true in the first quarter of 2020. Even as GDP growth fell by more than 13 percent, retail growth fell by 27 percent, fixed asset investment fell by 22 percent, and exports fell by 15 percent, China’s urban surveyed unemployment increased a mere 0.7% to 5.9% total.

Both measures of unemployment need to be improved

Neither measure of unemployment reflects the real situation in the job market. The urban registered unemployment rate, for its part, only counts people who have self-registered with the government as unemployed, and who meet the conditions to be counted. Few people actually take the urban registered unemployment rate at face value.

The Chinese survey unemployment rate is an improvement over the urban registered unemployment rate. Internationally, unemployment statistics usually rely on household survey data, counting anyone who wants to work but is unable to find employment as unemployed. China’s methods for tabulating surveyed unemployment rate are generally up to international standards.

However, China’s survey unemployment rate does not fully account for migrant workers. When there is work to be had in the city, a migrant counts as a “worker,” but after losing their job in the city, a migrant worker can return to the countryside to be a farmer. No matter the economic situation, the migrant worker technically has a job, either as a worker in the city or as a farmer in their hometown. As a result, there is no unemployment problem among migrant workers according to the surveyed unemployment statistics.

In reality, many migrants may want to remain in the city even when the economic outlook is bad. Only a lack of work ultimately forces them to return to the countryside to farm. In reality, these people also belong to the ranks of the unemployed. The land is the migrant worker’s unemployment “insurance,” and the money they obtain working as a farmer is their insurance payout. The current surveys for urban and rural households count those farmers as employed, which is entirely unreasonable.

** The article here includes a number of graphs indicating that after the number of migrant workers increased every year from 2000 until 2019, the first quarter of 2020 saw a drop in urban migrant worker populations back to pre-2005 levels. **

According to the latest data from the National Bureau of Statistics, there were only 120 million migrant workers in China in the first quarter of 2020, a drop of fifty million migrant workers from the same period last year. Though many of them were unable to find jobs in cities and were forced to go to their villages, none of those fifty million people will be counted as unemployed.

The real unemployment rate might be around 20%

According to the National Bureau of Statistics, there were a total of 780 million employed persons across all industries at the end of 2018, 570 million of whom worked in secondary or tertiary industries. 150 million of those people were self-employed, more than half working in industries like hospitality and food services.

The economic shutdown has had an outsized impact on such people, as revenue in the foodservice industry fell by 43% in the first quarter, for example. It is estimated that thirty percent of self-employed people are currently still unable to operate their business, resulting in an additional forty-five million unemployed people.

There is no easy recovery

**The article details numbers indicating a steep decline in consumer demand and industrial profits**

A fall in incomes and an increase in unemployment will accelerate the general downward trend in the Chinese real estate market that predate the coronavirus outbreak. At present, real estate transactions in the country’s thirty largest cities have only recovered to about 80% of their level in previous years.

In March, the average house price fell by 5.9% on a month-by-month basis in Shanghai. This rate places Shanghai behind only Fuzhou (7.2%) and Dandong (8.6%). Nearly half of all second-tier cities saw a drop in real estate value. Since 67% of household wealth in China is tied up in real estate, this adjustment in housing prices is sure to affect consumption.

Therefore, we must be patient with the economic recovery. It is relatively simple to “suspend” all economic activities, but a far more extended process to resume business as usual. Many problems, such as reduced income, bankruptcy, and unemployment during periods of economic downturn have magnifying effects on each other…What’s more, there remains great uncertainty about when medicine will be able to defeat the coronavirus.

This article was translated by Coby Goldberg. Coby is a recent Princeton graduate interested in connecting with any scholars or journalists who need a research assistant for projects related to China. For a portfolio of his work, including a fascinating thesis on sci-fi in China, see his dropbox here.


Congratulations to Danny, ChinaTalk’s first essay contest winner. He is a literary translator and freelance writer living in Beijing and has a personal blog.

Visually striking, the speech opens with a roaring claque of Xi’s merry men enjoining claps from an off-camera audience. Our ears are seized by one unknown enthusiast’s bellowing, then before we felt ready, Xi’s speech is already in full flow. As we try to catch up with his message, we watch him shuffle-padding around centre-stage while an array of eminence grise[s] sporting his fashionable tracksuit/v-neck combo do their best to keep formation behind.

It is heartening that amidst China’s deepest crisis in decades, the rarely seen leader&co appear to have taken time out of a busy schedule of public absences to come and say impromptu things about Xi’an Jiaotong university’s history.

This is a special moment. It is among few times in some years that we have had a recording of Xi dada expressing himself free from editing, beautification, choreographed props or a teleprompter to help him keep to Xi Jinping thought (and stay accurate with w Mandarin’s 4 tricky tones.) In spite of limited resources, Xi performs perfunctorily, merging the rhetorical skills of a CCTV propagandist anchor with his cuddly 温柔 [tender] charm.

Maintaining the Party’s resolute stance, Xi conveys a message about the need for adherence to the all important Party line. We are advised that among other things, loyalty will bring the great rejuvenation for China’s people. A message of faith is imparted, echoing Christ’s exhortation, ‘lay down your nets and follow me’, we are told that new life will come if we listen to and follow the Party line.

In a bid to add flesh to his message, Xi harks back to a forced march in the glory days of the anti-rightist movement that took Shanghai Jiaotong’s staff/students to Xi’an. Tactfully he tells the various Xi’an based onlookers that moving to Xi’an was a hardship posting involving great sacrifice for those patriotic Shanghai-ren that took up the call... Why did they do it then? Because they were voluntarily uprooted by Party directive!

The untold history surrounding this is quite a good micro-history that sums up various irksome government actions over the Maoist period. As with many policies that are formulated in closed-rooms by ideologues with their advisors/experts/rightists excluded, shortly after being promulgated this national strategy was quickly revealed to be unnecessary and ill-conceived. However, since the movement had begun, backtracking to Shanghai was deemed impossible/embarrassing. So, those whose lives had been uprooted from Shanghai were now unnecessarily in Xi’an and would stay there. The result of this government intervention eventually led to a schism where Shanghai Jiaotong found inter-national management challenging and soon abandoned its new branch, cutting colleagues off from each other, serendipitously for Xi’s speech, the resulting severing of ties led to the glorious birth of a new school!

Through this seemingly trivial story of the establishment of Xi’an Jiaotong, Xi explains to us that even though vassal-like obsequious obeisance may mean you lose your home because of an unnecessary policy (later decided to be pointless), it could also bring great abstract rewards such as national rejuvenation (at some point.) Hurrah for that.


I’m in the process of launching a spinoff podcast discussing Chinese tv. If anyone has good ideas for a title let me know!


China Twitter Tweets of the Week

Twitter avatar for @XiranJayZhao
XIRAN, Chinese History Educational Shitposter @XiranJayZhao
Cheat thread to the Chinese dynasties - XIA: School founder you see on plaques and statues everywhere but you have no idea what they actually did SHANG: Early principle who appears in black and white photos, but you hear a lot of tea about how he was horrible and problematic
11:22 PM ∙ May 11, 2020
1,090Likes461Retweets

Thread. So good. My faves were:

Twitter avatar for @XiranJayZhao
XIRAN, Chinese History Educational Shitposter @XiranJayZhao
ZHOU: Prim and proper principle who was principle FOREVER, so long that he got too old to command respect and the school turned to chaos QIN: Emo bullied goth kid who terrorizes the whole school and murders basically everyone with a knife, gets promptly arrested
11:23 PM ∙ May 11, 2020
180Likes16Retweets

From the same author:

Twitter avatar for @XiranJayZhao
XIRAN, Chinese History Educational Shitposter @XiranJayZhao
12 years ago, I could barely speak English. 3 years ago, this was an anime shitpost account called WeeblordJay. BUT GUESS WHO HAS A BOOK DEAL FOR A MECHA PILOT REIMAGINING OF WU ZETIAN, THE ONLY FEMALE EMPEROR IN CHINESE HISTORY SIGN UP FOR UPDATES AT xiranjayzhao.com
Image
10:30 PM ∙ Mar 17, 2020
6,231Likes1,177Retweets
Twitter avatar for @HangdaZhang
Hangda Zhang @HangdaZhang
I heard humor helps. vm.tiktok.com/3mbgVk/
Image
12:29 AM ∙ May 12, 2020
450Likes72Retweets
Twitter avatar for @PLMattis
Peter Mattis @PLMattis
I’m taking this seriously because this argument is being used inside and outside gov’t., so this is going to be a thread. I care less about what direction policy goes (OK, I have preferences) than I care that the US approach is based in reality. 1/30
Twitter avatar for @shifrinson
Josh Shifrinson @shifrinson
IR & Most China Scholars: "Don't listen to cheap talk, it can often be for a domestic political purpose." China Hawks: "ONLY LISTEN TO CHEAP TALK!" [note: the disjuncture between what Sov leaders claimed their ambitions were & actual Sov policy was huge] https://t.co/FhGpbD4Y4A
9:08 PM ∙ May 10, 2020
585Likes266Retweets

thread

Twitter avatar for @xujnx
Jin Xu @xujnx
2 lead-glazed bowls, both with brownish interior & bright green exterior. L came from the Northern Qi dyn, North China, 6C. R from Asia Minor of Roman Empire, 1C. Just another evidence for the transformation of Chinese art in 6C thanks to the cultural exchange on the Silk Road.
Image
Image
5:14 PM ∙ May 8, 2020
104Likes32Retweets
Twitter avatar for @xujnx
Jin Xu @xujnx
What have been excavated at Shimao in Shaanxi over the past decade are perhaps more significant than the terracotta army of the First Emperor. The magnificent 4000-year-old city, built mostly of stone, challenges many conventional notions about the birth of Chinese civilization.
Image
Image
Image
6:08 AM ∙ May 10, 2020
568Likes210Retweets

Thread. So glad I discovered Chinese archaeology twitter!

Twitter avatar for @slam_asian
SLAM: Asian Art @slam_asian
Army Assault on Taiwan, Nobushige, 1894 slam.org/collection/obj… #museumarchive #artmuseum
Image
3:06 PM ∙ May 10, 2020
Twitter avatar for @ChuBailiang
Chris Buckley 储百亮 @ChuBailiang
Goodbye China — for now. My time here is ending after 24 years. I am filled with sadness at leaving, and gratitude for family and friends who have made this country my life as well as my work. I look forward to resuming reporting soon, and also to the day when we can return.
Image
4:23 AM ∙ May 8, 2020
10,968Likes1,537Retweets
Twitter avatar for @CCCblogUoW
The Contemporary China Centre Blog @CCCblogUoW
to gently blow your mind for a moment: zoom in on this one and you will see there is a propaganda poster on the wall next to the door that was in fact a real propaganda poster from 1975. the layers of propaganda. i cannot.
Image
Image
Twitter avatar for @CCCblogUoW
The Contemporary China Centre Blog @CCCblogUoW
From the @UniWestArc China Visual Arts Project Children Health Check Day (nd [1940-1990]) Barefoot doctor listens to a boy's heart through a stethoscope. Other children wait, and more are coming through the door https://t.co/r5WJJeJBZX https://t.co/wG00dLDXiW
12:29 PM ∙ May 7, 2020
17Likes6Retweets
Twitter avatar for @CCCblogUoW
The Contemporary China Centre Blog @CCCblogUoW
From the @UniWestArc China Visual Arts Project Children Health Check Day (nd [1940-1990]) Barefoot doctor listens to a boy's heart through a stethoscope. Other children wait, and more are coming through the door westminster-atom.arkivum.net/index.php/cpc-…
Image
12:21 PM ∙ May 7, 2020
Twitter avatar for @AntiokhosE
Antiokhos in the East @AntiokhosE
Two years on, and still my favourite Chinese mistranslation....
Image
6:29 PM ∙ May 6, 2020
1,620Likes484Retweets

Thanks so much for reading! Please consider donating to my patreon.

Share this post

Just How Bad is Unemployment in China?

www.chinatalk.media
Comments
TopNewCommunity

No posts

Ready for more?

© 2023 Jordan Schneider
Privacy ∙ Terms ∙ Collection notice
Start WritingGet the app
Substack is the home for great writing