What's missing is the importance of alliances. GDP of the US alone is more or less the same as China plus Russia. GDP of all NATO states plus Japan and Korea is more than twice as large. Destroying alliances has a cost; it must be hoped at least the great viziers of Trumpistan will realize that (the sultan himself won't).
Really great deep-dive into this topic. I’m curious though where potential national security personnel like Elbridge Colby or Marco Rubio fit in this quadrant? I’m assuming Colby would be a “prioritizer” while Rubio would be a “primacist”?
This is an excellent first cut at what's coming and how to start thinking about 2025 and forward. The 2x2 captures the dynamic very well. My sense is that the prioritizers will have the ball first and a lot turns on how well or poorly they deal with the actual reality on the ground.
Of course! It's the stupid quadrant that will have power under trump (kill CHIPS, million percent tariff on everything, foreign aid to Putin!). We're going to get belligerent blister and policy to rot American power, production, and innovation as quickly as possible..
I'm not so sure—although I cannot rule it out, every administration comes in with a big agenda and confronts reality. It's hard to see Arizona Republicans voting against CHIPS when TSMC has a large facility just outside of Phoenix (where I live), as well as that seems such a lower priority than all many other things the administration will have to deal with.
Have you watched the last eight years?! Arizona Republicans will vote to kill their own children with measles (RFK at HHS) and take away their own jobs if he starts demagoguing them and threatening a primary.
I can see you still have a lot of feelings to process about yesterday. So maybe circle back when you're feeling better.
But to answer your question, yes. Politicians are single minded seekers of reelection. And many of them know that the most Trumpian candidates lost in 2018, 2020, and 2022. Kari Lake just lost, "bigly" (to coin a phrase), for the second straight time. The reason many Republicans were cow towing to Trump these last eight years are the same reason I expect that they'll start to break their own way: eventually his influence will fade (as it has for Obama, Bush, and Clinton). Of course it never goes away, but eventually partisans start looking to the next race, the next king-maker, and the next election.
What's missing is the importance of alliances. GDP of the US alone is more or less the same as China plus Russia. GDP of all NATO states plus Japan and Korea is more than twice as large. Destroying alliances has a cost; it must be hoped at least the great viziers of Trumpistan will realize that (the sultan himself won't).
Really great deep-dive into this topic. I’m curious though where potential national security personnel like Elbridge Colby or Marco Rubio fit in this quadrant? I’m assuming Colby would be a “prioritizer” while Rubio would be a “primacist”?
Seems right yes!
I track Rubio as an internationalist. See my follow up essay: https://scholars-stage.org/republican-debates-on-china-a-political-compass/
This is an excellent first cut at what's coming and how to start thinking about 2025 and forward. The 2x2 captures the dynamic very well. My sense is that the prioritizers will have the ball first and a lot turns on how well or poorly they deal with the actual reality on the ground.
Of course! It's the stupid quadrant that will have power under trump (kill CHIPS, million percent tariff on everything, foreign aid to Putin!). We're going to get belligerent blister and policy to rot American power, production, and innovation as quickly as possible..
I'm not so sure—although I cannot rule it out, every administration comes in with a big agenda and confronts reality. It's hard to see Arizona Republicans voting against CHIPS when TSMC has a large facility just outside of Phoenix (where I live), as well as that seems such a lower priority than all many other things the administration will have to deal with.
Have you watched the last eight years?! Arizona Republicans will vote to kill their own children with measles (RFK at HHS) and take away their own jobs if he starts demagoguing them and threatening a primary.
I can see you still have a lot of feelings to process about yesterday. So maybe circle back when you're feeling better.
But to answer your question, yes. Politicians are single minded seekers of reelection. And many of them know that the most Trumpian candidates lost in 2018, 2020, and 2022. Kari Lake just lost, "bigly" (to coin a phrase), for the second straight time. The reason many Republicans were cow towing to Trump these last eight years are the same reason I expect that they'll start to break their own way: eventually his influence will fade (as it has for Obama, Bush, and Clinton). Of course it never goes away, but eventually partisans start looking to the next race, the next king-maker, and the next election.
thanks for the compliment!