17 Comments
User's avatar
tata's avatar

Very nice post! I was in Kyrgyzstan a few weeks ago and thought it was very nice

Expand full comment
Torches Together's avatar

Nice review! I visited this time last year.

I loved visiting the Dungan (东干) people in Karakol. They arrived in Kyrgyzstan in the late Qing. They still speak a Shaanxi dialect (I could understand maybe 40%), but can't read Chinese characters. They even had books of folk tales written in Cyrillic that they could read in their dialect. It kind of felt like visiting a China that no longer exists. Also made me realise how rare it is in the mainland to hear young Northern dialect speakers who don't speak Mandarin.

Expand full comment
Jordan Schneider's avatar

insane

Expand full comment
Ben Westhoff's avatar

Incredible post, would have just liked this information higher: "players ride horses and compete to throw a 90lb (40kg) dead goat into an elevated pit."

Expand full comment
Jordan Schneider's avatar

this is a great youtube deep dive

Expand full comment
yuma's avatar

Turned down an opportunity to study Russian in Kyrgyzstan for a summer back in college… to my lasting regret! Great post—fascinating to learn about local perceptions of Chinese investment.

Expand full comment
Godfrey Firth's avatar

Great post Lily!

Expand full comment
Lily Ottinger's avatar

Thank you very much!

Expand full comment
Misha Skurikhin's avatar

But who was the first ChinaTalk listener in Kyrgyzstan?

Expand full comment
Jordan Schneider's avatar

the world may never know!

Expand full comment
Alec Feygin's avatar

This is great! Curious what you heard and saw when it comes to other Americans or American influence in Kyrgyzstan?

Expand full comment
Lily Ottinger's avatar

I saw some USAID-funded schools in the countryside and met some American backpackers, but in general, Chinese investment was much more visible and extensive. I did hear a lot of American music in taxis, though!

Expand full comment
Ivan Encinas's avatar

This reminds me of when I went to Kazakhstan a few years ago. It was so different from all the other places that I had visited. Really good food, weird (in a good way) architecture, and super nice people. I’m sure Kyrgyzstan isn’t too far off.

Expand full comment
Matilda's avatar

Очень интересная рецензия

Expand full comment
Lily Ottinger's avatar

Спасибо тебе Тилдочка!

Expand full comment
mmf's avatar

How do Kyrgyz feel about environmental impacts of.Chinese projects and protection of rare.species like snow leopards? Do they identify with these challenges or shrug them off?

Expand full comment
Lee S's avatar

Great post - awesome to learn more about such an undiscovered country. Would be curious about crypto trends there and if stablecoin adoption has proliferated / the digital banking scene broadly.

Expand full comment